AI · MEDIA · ONLINE DECEPTIONBefore you believe it, check it
Another AI LieEvidence before belief
Menu
←Round #5 · Picture 5 · 23 October 2026

A sawfish and a turtle swimming through pale, milky shallow water, seen from above: real or AI?

As shared

Photograph by Matt Deakin, shared on X by @peeperlab · Shown as an embedded post · Source

REAL

This is real.

How sure we areVery high

Based on 3 strong and 0 supporting pieces of evidence.

What we found

The photograph shows a green sawfish, a critically endangered species, swimming beside a green turtle in pale shallow water, seen from directly above. It is called Ethereal Encounter and drew wide attention after it won a major prize on 28 August 2026. Matt Deakin, a drone photographer from Broome, took it with a camera on a drone in waters off the Pilbara in Western Australia. The South Australian Museum announced it as the overall winner of the 2026 Australian Geographic Nature Photographer of the Year, chosen from 2,129 entries. The museum says the drone was about 2.5 kilometres away, with its battery alarm sounding and the light fading, when the sawfish swam through a group of turtles. Deakin told Digital Camera World that people keep asking him if it is AI, and that he does not take this as an insult. A named photographer, a judged competition and a museum exhibition are strong signs that an unlikely picture is real.

Key facts

Original source
Photograph by Matt Deakin, shared on X by @peeperlab
First published
Not recorded
Earlier appearances
Not recorded
The claim you saw
No caption recorded
Signs of AI
None that decide it

The evidence, strongest first

Supporting Points the same way

None.

Weak Shown, not relied on

How it looksThe sawfish has the right shape, with a long flat snout edged with evenly spaced teeth. The turtle's shell and flippers are in proportion. The haze is even across the frame, as shallow water full of sand looks from a drone. Nothing in the picture melts into anything else.

Detector scores are often wrong, so they never decide a verdict here.

What we couldn’t establish

Anything about the moment it shows beyond what the sources above record. If you know more, tell us.

Bottom line

Real: the original source shows it.

See the original ↗Think we’re wrong?

Was this explanation useful? ·

Check something like this yourself

Start with where it came from: reverse-search the picture, then find who posted it first. Or paste it into our free checker.

More like this

Think you can tell?
Five new pictures every Friday.
Play this week’s round